Loading page
Homes for Sale in Oneonta, NY
A college city market at the south end of the county
Oneonta is the other half of Otsego County, and it runs on something completely different from Cooperstown. SUNY Oneonta and Hartwick College anchor the population, which gives the city a deeper rental and multi-family market than anywhere else in the county.
On the Ground
Buying and Selling in Oneonta
For investors that means the numbers come first: rent roll, vacancy between academic years, the condition of the mechanicals, and whether the tax assessment is about to move. Student-occupied multi-family trades on those figures rather than on finishes, and we pull them before you get attached to a building.
For owner occupants Oneonta offers more house per dollar than the north end of the county, along with the practical trade-offs of a city: closer neighbors, older systems, and blocks that vary more than the listing photos suggest. Which street a house sits on matters here.
What comes up most in Oneonta
- Student rental and multi-family investment near both campuses
- Rent roll, vacancy, and operating cost review
- Owner occupied homes at south county pricing
- Block by block read on older city housing stock
100 Active Now
Available in Oneonta
See all 100 in Oneonta
Start Looking
Search Oneonta
Market Snapshot · September 2026
Otsego County by the Numbers
Median Sales Price
$185,000
-12.4%
Median Price / SqFt
$120
-24.5%
Closed Sales
13
-61.8%
New Listings
32
-49.2%
Active Inventory
180
+20%
Median Days on Market
77 days
-11.5%
These are single family sales across all of Otsego County for September 2026, not Oneonta alone. A village market can move very differently from its county, which is why the figures sit below the local read rather than above it. Percentages compare the same period a year earlier. Figures come from the regional MLS feed and are refreshed monthly.
Also in the Area