HOMESFARMSANDLAND
BuySell
    • Featured Properties
    • Property Showcases
    • Latest Blogs
      • Overview
      • Explore Open Houses
      • Discover Rental Living
      • Escape to Cabin Life
      • Unlock Multi-Family Living
      • Your Perfect Land Awaits
      • Embrace Farm Life
      • Overview
      • Find Rentals
      • Find Cabins
      • Browse Homes
      • Browse Farms
      • Browse Lands
    • Saved Properties
    • Overview
    • Buying Form
    • Buying Process
    • Mortgage Calculator
    • Overview
    • Selling Form
    • Selling Process
    • Free Home Evaluation
      • All of Otsego
      • Cooperstown
      • Oneonta
      • West Oneonta
      • Milford
      • Hartwick
      • Worcester
      • Unadilla
      • Laurens
      • Richfield Springs
      • All of Schoharie
      • Cobleskill
      • Middleburgh
      • Schoharie
      • Sharon Springs
      • Summit
      • Richmondville
      • Esperance
      • All of Chenango
      • Norwich
      • Oxford
      • Greene
      • Bainbridge
      • Sherburne
      • All of Delaware
      • Delhi
      • Stamford
      • Andes
      • Walton
      • Margaretville
      • Roxbury
      • Sidney
      • All of Greene
      • Catskill
      • Windham
      • Hunter
      • Cairo
      • Coxsackie
      • Athens
      • All of Broome
      • Binghamton
      • Vestal
      • Endicott
      • All of Oneida
      • New Hartford
      • Utica
      • Marcy
      • Clinton
      • All of Montgomery
      • Amsterdam
      • Fort Plain
      • Canajoharie
      • Fonda
      • All of Ulster
      • Kingston
      • New Paltz
      • Saugerties
      • Woodstock
      • Marlborough
    • Overview
    • Free Vendor List
    • Practical Guides
    • Need Funding?
    • Property Inspector
    • Down Payment Eligibility
    • Location Sharing?
      • Overview
      • Standard Operating Procedure
      • NYS Buyer-Seller
      • NYS Landlord-Tenant
      • Tenant Rights Notice
      • Fair Housing Notice
      • Privacy Policy
      • Location Services
      • Properties Preferences
      • Map Data Attribution
    • Who We Are
    • Meet the Team
Featured
Featured Properties
Property Showcases
Latest Blogs
Search
Advanced Search
Explore Open Houses
Discover Rental Living
Escape to Cabin Life
Unlock Multi-Family Living
Your Perfect Land Awaits
Embrace Farm Life
Search by Map
Find Rentals
Find Cabins
Browse Homes
Browse Farms
Browse Lands
Saved Properties
Buy
Buying Form
Buying Process
Mortgage Calculator
Sell
Selling Form
Selling Process
Free Home Evaluation
HOMESFARMSANDLAND
  • Otsego
  • Schoharie
  • Chenango
  • Delaware
  • Greene
  • Broome
  • Oneida
  • Montgomery
  • Ulster

Select a county to see cities

Resources
Free Vendor List
Practical Guides
Need Funding?
Property Inspector
Down Payment Eligibility
Location Sharing?
Disclosures
Standard Operating Procedure
NYS Buyer-Seller
NYS Landlord-Tenant
Tenant Rights Notice
Fair Housing Notice
Privacy Policy
Location Services
Properties Preferences
Map Data Attribution
About
Who We Are
Meet the Team

Let's Find Your Next Property.

HOMESFARMSANDLAND.COM

Kevin Lucero

Lic. Real Estate Salesperson

a Charlotteville Realty Team

Independently Owned & Operated

607-282-6242kevin@homesfarmsandland.com

Buying

  • Buying Form
  • Buying Process
  • Mortgage Calculator

Selling

  • Selling Form
  • Selling Process
  • Free Home Evaluation

About Us

  • Who We are
  • Meet the Team

Resources

  • Latest Blogs
  • Free Vendor List
  • PracticalGuides
  • Need Funding?
  • Property Inspector
  • Down Payment Eligibility

Communities

  • Otsego County
  • Schoharie County
  • Chenango County
  • Delaware County
  • Greene County
  • Broome County
  • Oneida County
  • Montgomery County
  • Ulster County

Disclosures

  • Standard Operating Procedure
  • NYS Buyer-Seller
  • NYS Landlord-Tenant
  • Tenant Rights Notice
  • Fair Housing Notice
  • Privacy Policy
  • Location Services
  • Properties Preferences
  • Map Data Attribution

© 2026 Homes, Farms & Land. All rights reserved.

Property at 5736 Plum Brook Road, Great Valley, NY 14741
CLOSED
0
$375,000

5736 Plum Brook RoadGreat Valley, NY, 14741

4 Beds2 Baths2,016 SqFt4.9 Acres
Nestled on 5 picturesque acres just five minutes from the charming Village of Ellicottville and the slopes of Holiday Valley Resort and Holi Mont, this inviting country Cape Cod offers the perfect blend of rural tranquility and year-round recreation. Featuring four spacious bedrooms and two full bathrooms, the home combines classic charm with comfortable living spaces ideal for gathering with family and friends. An expansive deck overlooks the surrounding hills and in winter, the view opens up for miles. A standout feature is the impressive detached garage/barn, complete with a 2-bay garage, first floor hobby room, and an insulated, heated workshop on the second level—perfect for hobbies, projects, or additional storage. Surrounded by rolling fields, mountains, and a peaceful, private setting, yet close to one of Western New York’s premier four-season destinations, this property is a rare find for those seeking both serenity and convenience. Whether you envision it as a primary residence, vacation getaway, or hobby farm, this country retreat is ready to welcome you home. Ask Chat GPT

Est. Monthly

$1,777/MO

$375,000

5736 Plum Brook Road, Great Valley, NY

4 Beds2 Baths2,016 SqFt4.9 Acres

Nestled on 5 picturesque acres just five minutes from the charming Village of Ellicottville and the slopes of Holiday Valley Resort and Holi Mont, this inviting country Cape Cod offers the perfect blend of rural tranquility and year-round recreation. Featuring four spacious bedrooms and two full bathrooms, the home combines classic charm with comfortable living spaces ideal for gathering with family and friends. An expansive deck overlooks the surrounding hills and in winter, the view opens up for miles. A standout feature is the impressive detached garage/barn, complete with a 2-bay garage, first floor hobby room, and an insulated, heated workshop on the second level—perfect for hobbies, projects, or additional storage. Surrounded by rolling fields, mountains, and a peaceful, private setting, yet close to one of Western New York’s premier four-season destinations, this property is a rare find for those seeking both serenity and convenience. Whether you envision it as a primary residence, vacation getaway, or hobby farm, this country retreat is ready to welcome you home. Ask Chat GPT

StatusClosed
Property TypeResidential
Property SubtypeSingle Family Residence
Year Built1991
Total Rooms10 rooms
Days on Market97 days

Est. Monthly Payment

$1,777.49

%
%
yr

Private Mortgage Insurance

Not required

Affordability Checkoptional
$

Enter your annual income to check affordability

Property Details

Property Information

5736 Plum Brook Road

Great Valley, NY 14741 • Cattaraugus
4
Beds
2
Baths
2,016
SqFt
4.9
Acres
Status
Closed
Property Type
Residential
Property Subtype
Single Family Residence
Year Built
199135 years ago
Total Rooms
10 rooms
Days on Market
97 days
Tax History
Estimated values, may not reflect current amounts.
  • Annual Tax Amount
    $4,372
Property History
  • Closed
    Nov 12, 2025 • NYSAMLS • B1629292
    $375,000
  • Listed for sale
    Aug 7, 2025 • NYSAMLS • B1629292
    $375,000
Mortgage Calculator
Estimated monthly payment for this property
$1,777.49
Down Payment
Interest Rate
Loan Term
%
%
yearsyrs.
Affordability Checkoptional
$

Enter your annual income to see if this home fits your budget

Private Mortgage Insurance

Not required — down payment above 20%
MLS Information
  • Source
    NYSAMLS
  • MLS#
    B1629292
  • Listing Office
    ERA Team VP Real Estate
  • Last Updated
    63 days ago

Appliances

  • Appliances
    • Dryer
    • Dishwasher
    • Gas Oven
    • Gas Range
    • Microwave
    • Propane Water Heater
    • Refrigerator
    • Washer

Climate & Systems

  • Heating
    • Electric
    • Propane
    • Baseboard
    • Hot Water

Interior Features

  • Flooring
    • Carpet
    • Tile
    • Varies
  • Basement
    • Full
    • Finished
    • Walk Out Access
  • Interior Features
    • Breakfast Bar
    • Ceiling Fans
    • Dining Area
    • Entrance Foyer
    • Separate Formal Living Room
    • Living Dining Room
    • Main Level Primary
    • Workshop

Parking

  • Parking Features
    • Detached
    • Garage
    • Heated Garage
    • Storage
    • Workshop In Garage
    • Circular Driveway
  • Garage Spaces
    2

Lot & Grounds

  • Lot Size
    4.9 acres
  • Lot Features
    • Irregular Lot
    • Rural Lot
    • Secluded
  • Exterior Features
    • Gravel Driveway
    • Propane Tank Leased

Type

  • Property Type
    Residential
  • Property Subtype
    Single Family Residence
  • Architectural Style
    Cape Cod

Structure

  • Construction
    Vinyl Siding
  • Roof
    Asphalt
  • Foundation
    Block

Condition

  • Year Built
    1991
  • Condition
    Resale
  • Days on Market
    97 days
  • Water
    Well
  • Sewer
    Septic Tank
  • Utilities
    High Speed Internet Available

607-282-6242, (607) 282-6242, or +1 607 282 6242

Kevin Lucero

Kevin Lucero

Lic. Real Estate Salesperson

CallEmail
Picked for you

Similar Properties

Handpicked listings that match what you're looking at

View all →
  • 8989 Chidsey Hill Road, Pulteney, NY 14418ACTIVE$338,000

    8989 Chidsey Hill Road, Pulteney, NY 14418

    4 Beds2 Baths2,072 SqFt2.59 Acres

    LISTING BY KEUKA LAKE & LAND REALTY BATH

  • 52 Beechwood Road, New Hartford, NY 13413ACTIVE$338,500

    52 Beechwood Road, New Hartford, NY 13413

    4 Beds1 Bath1,700 SqFt0.3 Acres

    LISTING BY MOHAWK VALLEY 1ST CHOICE REALTY LLC

  • 209 California Drive, Amherst, NY 14221ACTIVE$339,000OPEN 6/20

    209 California Drive, Amherst, NY 14221

    4 Beds1.5 Baths2,053 SqFt0.1521 Acres

    LISTING BY HOWARD HANNA WNY INC.

  • 13 Van Buren Road, Glenville, NY 12302ACTIVE$339,000OPEN 6/20

    13 Van Buren Road, Glenville, NY 12302

    3 Beds2.5 Baths1,868 SqFt0.37 Acres

    LISTING BY SIGNATURE ONE REALTY GROUP LLC

  • 626 Parker Hill Road, Burlington, NY 13335ACTIVE$339,000

    626 Parker Hill Road, Burlington, NY 13335

    4 Beds2 Baths1,252 SqFt5 Acres

    LISTING BY KELLER WILLIAMS UPSTATE NY PROPERTIES

  • 5042 County Road 33, Bristol, NY 14424ACTIVE$339,000

    5042 County Road 33, Bristol, NY 14424

    2 Beds1.5 Baths1,056 SqFt8.6 Acres

    LISTING BY CASSARA REALTY GROUP

  • 2417 Onativia Road, Lafayette, NY 13084ACTIVE$339,000

    2417 Onativia Road, Lafayette, NY 13084

    3 Beds2 Baths1,274 SqFt2.5 Acres

    LISTING BY E XP REALTY

  • 543 E Campbell Avenue, Sherrill, NY 13461ACTIVE$339,000

    543 E Campbell Avenue, Sherrill, NY 13461

    3 Beds2 Baths2,008 SqFt0.343 Acres

    LISTING BY KAY REAL ESTATE

  • 8540 Hayes Hollow Road, Colden, NY 14033ACTIVE$339,000

    8540 Hayes Hollow Road, Colden, NY 14033

    3 Beds3 Baths1,355 SqFt4.62 Acres

    LISTING BY CHUBB-AUBREY LEONARD REAL ESTATE

  • 1460 Lamoy Road, Sullivan, NY 13037ACTIVE$339,000

    1460 Lamoy Road, Sullivan, NY 13037

    4 Beds2 Baths1,456 SqFt2.8 Acres

    LISTING BY HUNT REAL ESTATE ERA