Est. Monthly
$6,517/MO
20 Crescent Way, Shelter Island, NY
Tucked on nearly an acre in a quiet, established neighborhood, this 2,175 sq. ft. home offers the rare combination of privacy, location, and room to grow. The light-filled upper level features a cathedral-ceiling living room with fireplace and sliders to an entertainment deck, a primary suite, and three bedrooms in all. Easy access to Menhaden Lane Beach and golf. A fully enclosed yard with room for a pool and expansion makes this your blank canvas on the Island.
Est. Monthly Payment
$6,517.46
Private Mortgage Insurance
Not required
July 19, 2026
Private Mortgage Insurance
Handpicked listings that match what you're looking at