Assembled estates of this scale simply do not exist within Sag Harbor Village's historic core - and this offering is the exception. Uniting the stately main residence at 9 Suffolk Street with the private retreat at 12 Amity Street, this compound of two single and separate properties delivers nearly 5,000 square feet across 9 bedrooms and 6.5 bathrooms on a commanding footprint just moments from Main Street and the harbor. A separate historic barn has another legal bedroom, and designs for full bath, powder room and kitchen given Village ADU approval. It is a scale of ownership almost never available on one of the Village's most coveted lanes - the privacy of a private compound with the walkability of Village life. 9 Suffolk Street anchors the compound with 3,400 square feet of pedigreed architecture - 5 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms, and centuries of character rendered fresh through elevated modern design. Sun-filled parlors and original historic millwork open onto sweeping porches built for multi-season entertaining, while the landscaped grounds enclose a private outdoor sanctuary centered on a heated gunite pool - a rare luxury this deep in the historic district. 12 Amity Street, sited directly adjacent, extends the compound with 1,500 square feet of individual charm across 3 bedrooms and 2.5 bathrooms - with the Amity main house offering a sweet, light-filled character all its own, from its intimate scale to its inviting covered porch. At the rear of the property is the beautifully restored historic barn with ADU approvals in place, to create a fully legal sanctuary dwelling complete with an additional bedroom, potential full bath, powder room and kitchen across its two light-filled levels. It serves as the natural connector between the two addresses. There is coveted off-street parking for at least 6 vehicles. Together, the two addresses - each single and separate, yet seamlessly joined by the reimagined barn - form something the Village rarely offers at any price: a true multi-house compound with the scale for multi-generational living, effortless large-scale hosting, or exceptional income potential, all without leaving the walkable heart of Sag Harbor. Assembled compounds of this size and pedigree, on adjacent parcels within the historic district, essentially do not come to market. This is that once-in-a-generation opportunity.