Loading page
Homes for Sale in Old Forge, NY
Adirondack Park camps and Fulton Chain waterfront
Old Forge sits at the northern end of Herkimer County, inside the Adirondack Park, and it runs on tourism and camp ownership. Nothing about buying here resembles buying in the valley villages ninety minutes south.
On the Ground
Buying and Selling in Old Forge
Buying inside the Park is its own process. Adirondack Park Agency classifications affect what can be built, subdivided, and cleared, and a parcel that looks buildable on a listing sheet may not be. That determination comes before the offer, not during attorney review.
Waterfront on the Fulton Chain trades on entirely different comparables than anything else in the county, and the differences that move price are specific: which lake, how the frontage sits, whether access is deeded or owned, and what the shoreline restrictions allow. Seasonal camps also carry their own questions about winter access, water systems, and year-round usability.
What comes up most in Old Forge
- Adirondack Park Agency classification and buildability review
- Fulton Chain waterfront and deeded access comparables
- Seasonal camps, winter access, and water system condition
- Tourism-driven rental potential and what is permitted
3 Active Now
Available in Old Forge
Start Looking
Search Old Forge
Market Snapshot · September 2026
Herkimer County by the Numbers
Median Sales Price
$195,900
-7.6%
Median Price / SqFt
$118
-21.2%
Closed Sales
13
-69.8%
New Listings
34
-59.5%
Active Inventory
189
+20.4%
Median Days on Market
88 days
+1.1%
These are single family sales across all of Herkimer County for September 2026, not Old Forge alone. A village market can move very differently from its county, which is why the figures sit below the local read rather than above it. Percentages compare the same period a year earlier. Figures come from the regional MLS feed and are refreshed monthly.
Also in the Area